You have probably encountered the opinion, that much more important than what you’re saying to your dog is how you’re saying it (the tone). But it shows, that dogs are able to understand the human language much better, than we generally credit them for.
This theory is based on a new study of researchers at the University of Loránd Eötvös in Budapest, which has been published in the Science magazine at the end of August.
The experiment took place on thirteen family dogs who live with their owners, mainly on border collies and Golden retrievers. The research workers trained the dogs to sit inside an fMRI scanner, which measures the activity of the brain.
The scientists recorded the voice of the trainer saying phrases in various kinds of intonation. They recorded a general phrase for praise with an approving tone, but also a number of neutral words with a neutral tone of voice including conjunctions, which don’t bear any specific meaning. They recorded also praises with a neutral tone and neutral phrases and words with an approving tone. Then, the scientists monitored the brain waves of the dogs, while they played them the recorded phrases.
To their surprise, they found out, that dogs process the words and the intonation used separately, in different parts of the brain. When they heard familiar words of praise, the active one was the left hemisphere of the brain – that one that is used by humans to process language. This activity occurred irrespectively of the tone that the trainer used.
The dogs reacted to the intonation of the phrase, however, in the right hemisphere – same as humans. Therefore, despite it seemed, that dogs process words irrespectively of the intonation, the tone that was used was not irrelevant.
The dog “centre of reward”, where positive attention is processed or, for example, food is processed as well, was stimulated, when the individuals heard words of praise with a positive intonation. In other words, dog will recognize praise irrespectively of the tone that it is being said in, but they register it as positive attention only in the case it is said using a positive tone.
The head researcher stated in his opinion, that praise can very well function as a reward, but it best works with positive intonation, or when the meaning of the words and the tone correlate. Not only do the dogs distinguish what we are saying and how we are saying it, but they can also connect both for correct interpretation of the meaning. Again, it is true, that this principle is very similar to the one, that is used by the human brain.
The results of the research necessarily don’t prove, that dogs understand the precise meaning of all the known words, but apart from other things, it implies, that they are capable of distinguishing between words that they have heard before and words that they have never heard.
Naturally, dog owner have long known, that they can use word commands to train the dogs and to communicate with them. But the head of research explains, that even the reaction of dogs on these commands are often difficult to separate from the tone of the voice and the body language.
Therefore, the main result of the study is not, that dogs can distinguish words, but that they distinguish words that are meaningful or meaningless for them, with the left brain hemisphere playing a major part.
And what about you, do you feel, like I do, that your furry friend often understands you only too well, and sometimes they don’t understand a thing (usually depending on what is more convenient for them at the moment :) )?
Although I sometimes temporarily care of some brown rats, I still consider myself to be a beginner in brown rat keeping. In the beginning of this year, a white lab brown rat ended up in my temporary care. I noticed that Běluše (that’s how I called her...
It sits with great difficulties. It also looks like it is very painful. It seems that any contact of the tail and ground causes great pain. As well as any touch when I try to find out what’s wrong with its tail. We came back from swimming where our dog...
Summer fun begins now. And I can’t imagine a summer without our activities together with my dog. What about you? Plan where you and your doggie could spend time before the temperatures are scorching and not a single branch moves on trees and we all...
Some dogs are already born with sensitive digestion, at some it may occur later in life. Or an allergy for a component of the food they used to like and we considered as suitable may occur. For such cases, meat cans can be a great supplement of normal...
If you decide to head to the streets of your city during a hot summer day, remember that pavements you will be walking on are much warmer that the air. In general, I try to go out with my dog during hot summer days as least as possible but if we go...
That brown rats are social rodents and love and look for the closeness of not only other brown rats but also their owners is a well-known fact. They feel lonely and sad without any interaction
Weekend or holiday is here and you are thinking about what to pack? You definitely shouldn’t forget your first-aid kit. And also the one for your dog! Properly equipped first-aid kit is a must. If you are struggling with deciding what should be...
Our personal experience is what influences us most in our opinions. But if we don’t have it or can’t get it at least from a friend or family member, it is more difficult for us to imagine how living with a giant furry friend looks like. And if it comes...
The best option for living of a small rodent are big aquariums, plastic boxes or cages. And I don’t mean big as high but rather with as big area as possible. Hamsters are naturally running creatures and need enough space. Max has a space of the...
If you are going for your holiday by car, you may be considering bringing another passenger with you. Your dog can be a great companion, so you don´t want to leave it at home. However, your time off by the sea might hide various obstacles, starting...
Turkey, the homeland of angoras and Turkish Vans is almost cats’ paradise. Even though veterinary care is quite expensive here, also cats living outside are taken care of well. Even in large cities like Istanbul and Ankara you can encounter a lot of...
When I was a child, our dog changed my life. He taught me lifetime love for living beings but also responsibility, patience and caring for others. Scientist has found out those are not the only benefits the life with an animal has for children....
