A cat or a dog? Scientists made a research on which of them is smarter

Have you ever discussed whether a cat or a dog is more intelligent with your friends? Reportedly, scientists already know the answer. In this article, I mention a few facts and observations from a recently published research paper on this topic.

Have you ever discussed whether a cat or a dog is more intelligent with your friends? Reportedly, scientists already know the answer. In this article, I mention a few facts and observations from a recently published research paper on this topic.

 

Scientists have finally figured out who is smarter – a cat or a dog. In a research published in Frontiers in Neuroanatomy magazine, the scientists focused not only on the size of animals’ brains but also on the number of neurons in their neocortex. These grey cells, Hercule Poirot counted on when solving complicated crimes, are connected to thinking, planning and complex behaviour.

 

And what did they find out? The result may be a surprise for some of you. Even though cats are able to spread kind of an aura of (not only) intellectual superiority, they have half of the neurons less than an average golden retriever. While dogs have about 530 million neurons, there are only about 250 million in a cat’s brain (for comparison, a human has ca. 16 billion).

 

Doctor Suzana Herculano-Houzel, a faculty member of Vanderbilt University in Tennessee focusing on psychology and natural sciences, believes that the absolute number of neurons of an animal and especially those in the neocortex defines its mental capabilities and abilities to predict what is going to happen in their surroundings based on previous experience. The conclusion is that dogs have the ability to do much more complex and flexible things with their lives than cats.

 

In this research, also the brains of ferrets, raccoons, mongoose, hyenas, lions and brown bears were also examined. This group of carnivores was chosen to contain various brain sizes of both domesticated and wild animals. Ferrets have the least neurons and bears have only one more neuron compared to cats. After retrievers, lions have the biggest number of neurons closely followed by hyenas.

 

Anyway, the research showed that many animals with large brains have a small number of neurons and vice versa. A golden retriever can stand as an example of this fact, it has more neurons than animals with three times bigger brains. On the contrary, a bear has the same number of neurons as a cat, even though it has a ten times larger brain.

 

According to Cellia Haddon, a cat behaviourist and an author of a book on this topic, the reason why cats have less neurons than dogs may be the fact they are not so social animals as dogs. Dogs’ origins are in wolves who hunt in a pack and that’s why they need to master complicated, complex behaviour to be able to cooperate. In contrast, cats who hunt and often even live alone do not have such skills.

 

But does that mean that dogs are more intelligent than cats? After all, they get full bowls of goodies, our care and attention without having to do anything for that :). A breeder club however noted that most dog owners think their pets are the more intelligent (what a surprise).

 

However, this research at least gives us the explanation why dogs are so versatile. The fact why dogs are useful in so many social roles, from police officers and assistance dogs to guide, search and rescue dogs.

 

So what about you, do you agree with the conclusion of the research? Or do you rather tend to agree with Celia Haddon that the fact cats do not have so complex behavioural skills as dogs and they are not so much social as dogs does not mean they are more stupid?

 

Related articles

How rescue dogs are trained

In the previous article, we wrote about what rescuing people entails and which dog breeds are suitable for searching for people in collapsed buildings. This topic is so interesting that we decided to focus even more on dog training itself, i.e. on the...

Cats are not vegetarians! What belongs to a cat bowl?

Let’s be clear, cats are carnivores by nature.  They love meat. It is completely natural for them. Meat must be the basis of their daily nutrition. A cat cannot live without meat! Cats instinctively prefer foods high in meat. Feeds with meat aroma and...

Dogs to the rescue - How are rescue dogs trained?

There are questions that run through a person’s mind upon seeing dogs searching for people lost in the woods, stuck under the rubble of a collapsed building or drowning in a reservoir. How difficult is it for a dog to find such people? Can I train my...

How to proceed when a dog runs astray?

It is an unenviable situation no four-legged companion´s owner would like to get into. When your dog runs astray during a walk, for example because it discovers a hole in the fence or senses another animal that catches its attention, many of us panic...

Physiotherapy-based defense training fundamentals

We, humans, do take care of our bodies and our health. If our knee hurts, we go to the orthopaedist, if our back hurts for a long time, we probably start considering physiotherapy. The need to go to inspections regularly increases with the level of...

Dogs at shows: What Does It Take?

At dog shows, many dog lovers meet to show off with their beloved pets of pure breed. However, such events are not only beauty pageants as they could seem. They are also important for breeding and for pure-bred dog to mate. What happens on such shows...

Christmas Dinner for Your Pets

One of the most important parts of Christmas is Christmas Eve’s dinner. For example in the Czech Republic, it usually includes fish soup, fried carp or schnitzel and potato salad. However, the most important thing is that all loved ones should be at...

Original Christmas Gifts for Cats

At Christmas, we want to make our loved ones, those who are our loyal companions throughout the whole year, happy. It also applies to our furry friends. If you have a cat at home and you are thinking about what to give it at Christmas, we have a...